BY MICHAEL CAIRNS, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
AFTER WATERSHED MOMENT OF EX-SENIOR DETECTIVE'S EVIDENCE AT OMAGH BOMB INQUIRY, IT'S TIME TO GET MORE INFORMATION FOR VICTIMS' FAMILIES.
The evidence of former senior detective Norman Baxter at the Omagh Inquiry was a watershed event in dealing with the legacy of the Troubles and a set of hearings which point to the necessary ingredients for an effective truth recovery process.
Over three days of giving his testimony to the inquiry lawyers, the former CID chief superintendent revealed his view that he'd been deliberately undermined by others in the security apparatus north and south of the border.
He said that evidence he wanted to review had been destroyed by unknown people “acting in coordination”, that the bomb was driven north by an informer working for both MI5 and the Garda and that he got to the point of not telling his superior officers about his plan to interview a suspect in England as he no longer knew who to trust.
His testimony was hugely beneficial to relatives of those killed and injured, in that it answered in part why so few of the stones Sir Ronnie Flanagan claimed would be turned, actually remained unturned.
It was also beneficial in supporting the vilified report of then Police Ombudsman, Nuala O'Loan, which first raised suspicions around buried intelligence information as did the disclosure to the inquiry by Mr Baxter that he was up against the tide of those protecting the peace process.
DUP and RUC
It has been notable that the DUP has not exploited the allegations around the need to keep the IRA South Armagh Brigade on board from someone.
Is this because so much of their base is ex-RUC or RUC reserve and the overall blocked investigation narrative undermines the delusion often heard from unionists that “it was the finest police force in the world”?
The inquiry environment in which the Baxter revelations were made looks and feels like a courtroom, but its purpose is to answer one question — could the bombing reasonably have been prevented by UK state authorities. No recommendations of action over criminality can emerge and those giving evidence are taken gently through a questioning process by the counsel to the inquiry.
The result was that he arrived prepared to give not only factual answers but also ones based on his deductions and beliefs shaped by years in an environment where often things were not as they seemed.
I have known many CID officers over the years and some Special Branch officers and in private the former have few good words to say about the latter as a result of many of them being told to back off or take another tack on criminal investigations.
Here in the inquiry environment, was a contributor who felt comfortable enough to voice that sentiment publicly.
Need for Standing Inquiry into Troubles
Ultimately the purpose of the inquiry is for Lord Turnbull to produce his report to the UK Government but like the Saville Inquiry in which Martin McGuinness had legal cover to give evidence without fear, the public inquiry format should be used as a template for a standing inquiry into Troubles killings.
The fact those on the security forces side are all now retired and free of career pressures should make more content to speak about their involvement if freedom from incrimination including breaking the official secrets act was guaranteed.
A list of terms of reference could address where the line should be drawn on official secrets, for instance names of agents. This would cut out the tortuous and expensive legal cases or threats of legal cases which has so perplexed the SAS that it has lifted its ban on former members speaking to the media.
For the IRA, which now seems to have morphed into an old comrades association, isn't it time for its volunteers to have the courage to help victims' relatives understand why they were chosen, how it was planned and carried out and if their agents embedded in areas like the civil service or post office played a role?
Chief Superintendent Baxter is clearly angry at how he was left trying to cope with the investigation into the largest terrorist attack in history prior to 9-11. But his willingness to open up and let the relatives and world know about the self-protecting nature of elements of RUC and Garda intelligence and political policy influence over MI5 has aided the search for a way forward on legacy which could work if those within the republican movement step away from their policy of telling victims the way forward is only via the courts.
When the Omagh report is delivered, the UK Government should evaluate the benefits of revisiting a public inquiry free from prosecution hearings system looking at its advantages in terms of reconciliation, healing and finance and end the cycle of endless taxpayer-funded court actions.
These inquiries would cover all Troubles-era killings for which no-one was tried and convicted with the primary aim of gaining information for victims' families.
An open question should be put out there to former IRA members as follows; If someone like ex-chief superintendent Baxter has the courage to question the action of his leadership, do you have the moral courage to do the same in a similar public environment?
Michael Cairns is a strategic communications adviser and former editor at BBC NI
Omagh and the price of peace
PATRICK MURPHY, Irish News, November 21st, 2026
IF one of those who transported the Omagh bomb was an agent of both the Garda and British intelligence service MI5, should the Dublin and London governments carry some responsibility for the deaths in the explosion?
Clearly, the Real IRA must be held accountable for the atrocity.
However, if British and Irish intelligence agencies could have prevented the bombing, surely their governments must now at least explain why they failed to intervene?
The issue arises following the evidence given recently to the Omagh Bombing Inquiry by retired Detective Chief Superintendent (DCS) Norman Baxter, who was the Senior Investigating Officer for the crime.
He claimed there was “a high level of probability” that the bomb could have been prevented by disrupting the work of those who had been responsible for earlier bombs in Moira, Portadown, Banbridge and Lisburn.
He believed that the Omagh bomb could have been intercepted at one point in the north and he said there had been “a sequence of events in the investigation which points to coordinated obstruction of the investigation”.
If what he says is true, there are two possible explanations for the governments’ behaviour: error, or intent.
Were they careless in not preventing the bombing, or did they somehow allow the bombers to have what Dr Baxter called “free rein” from the middle of 1997 until Omagh in August 1998?
Those of us outside the security services have no way of determining the truth.
However, if what DCS Baxter says has no basis in fact, we might expect the two governments to point that out.
Failure to do so would not prove that they deliberately allowed the bombing to go ahead, but it would suggest they have not been open about the role of their intelligence agencies.
So if the two governments declined the opportunity to prevent the bombing, why would they do that?
Possible explanations
Dr Baxter offered three possible explanations when replying to a question on why the police investigation had been hampered.
He said that based on “some reasonable understanding”, the reasons included protecting intelligence sources and shielding how the police operated.
It also included “political pressure not to disrupt the peace process”.
While the officer was speaking about the subsequent police investigation, there is historical precedent for British intelligence to allow acts of violence, including murder, to take place to protect an agent.
29 people including a woman pregnant with twins were killed in the 1998 Omagh bombing
If the alleged informer travelling in the car with the bomb had been intercepted, his cover would presumably have been blown.
The logic behind allowing agents a free hand is that their evil facilitates a greater good.
It is a highly dubious argument in philosophy and practice. St Thomas Aquinas, for example, taught that we cannot do evil so that good can come from it.
In practice, the Kenova Report said that the agent Stakeknife, widely identified as Freddie Scappaticci, probably cost more lives than he saved. His evil just produced more evil.
Despite its immorality, allowing state agents to engage in criminal activity can be perfectly legal in Britain. There does not appear to be similar authority in the Republic.
Any suggestion that the bomb might not have been intercepted to protect the peace process is a frightening one.
Good Friday Agreement
If the Dublin and London governments somehow allowed the bombing to go ahead (and we cannot say that they did), they could not have foreseen the scale of death and destruction. However, could someone have been prepared to risk human life to promote peace?
The bombing on August 15 came at a time when it was not clear if the political process would work.
The first Assembly elections had been held on June 25. The Assembly had met for the first time on July 1, but it existed only in shadow form until December 1999.
Public revulsion at the bombing completely altered the political atmosphere. The death and destruction were condemned by all political parties, including Sinn Féin, and there was now a widespread acceptance that the way ahead lay in politics, not violence.
So, could it have been the case that the British and/or Irish did not do all they could have done to prevent the bomb, so they could facilitate the establishment of the Stormont Assembly? We will probably never find out. Meanwhile, some might argue that good ultimately came from Omagh. However, the families of the victims would certainly claim that human life is more important than political strategy.
You will have your own view on that ethical debate.
You might begin by identifying what good has come from Stormont.
Memorial to bookmakers shop victims attacked for third time
CONNLA YOUNG, Irish News, November 21st, 2026
A MEMORIAL to five Catholics killed in the Sean Graham’s Bookmakers atrocity has been attacked for a third time in recent months.
Five people were murdered when a UDA gunman burst into the Ormeau Road bookmakers in south Belfast and opened fire on February 5 1992.
James Kennedy (15), Christy Doherty (51), William McManus (54), Jack Duffin (66) and Peter Magee (18), were all killed.
It is understood the paint bomb attack was carried out at around 4am on Friday by people on e-bikes who are believed to have travelled from the direction of east Belfast.
The memorial to the victims was also targeted when paint was thrown over it in September in an incident linked to rising parade tensions on the Garvaghy Road in Portadown.
Tributes to the dead were also damaged in a second attack last month
A memorial to five Catholics killed in the Sean Graham’s Bookmakers atrocity has been attacked again
The Ormeau Road was at the centre of a parading dispute in the 1990s after local people objected to loyal order marches going through the area.
In July 1992 Orangemen shouted pro-UDA slogans and taunted local residents by holding up five fingers – one for each of the dead – while passing the scene of the atrocity.
Tensions resurfaced earlier this month when the Apprentice Boys applied to the Parades Commission for a march through the majority nationalist district.
Although the parade was eventually banned there were allegations that loyalists taunted victims of the Sean Graham’s massacre with a five fingered gesture as they travelled through the Lower Ormeau area on a Translink bus.
Gerard Rice, of the Lower Ormeau Concerned Community group, spoke about the impact of the recent attack on relatives of the dead.
“They are just disgusted,” he said.
“And they are absolutely disgusted because political unionism somehow point that it’s…people on the Ormeau Road’s fault, or we are disbelieved, that we did it ourselves.
“People on the road are just disgusted at the whole thing, we never get just an absolute condemnation and calls for it to stop.
“We get some mad allegation, so the families are annoyed about that.”
Mr Rice pointed out the memorial simply pays tribute to those who died in the bookmakers.
“This is a Sean Graham’s memorial, it’s in relation to a massacre that happened,” he said.
“It’s attack on innocent families, there’s nothing political about this memorial.”
Mark Thompson of Relative for Justice slammed the latest attack as “yet another despicable sectarian hate filled attack on these bereaved families and those injured in this atrocity that involved state agents and collusion.
“Considering the amount of attacks in a short period linked to sectarian marches the lack of effective response from the PSNI must be addressed.”
Police have appealed for witnesses.
“Our investigation is underway and we are pursuing all investigative opportunities to bring those responsible before the courts,” said Superintendent Fionla Dorman.
“I would like to acknowledge the significant impact of this and previous incidents on bereaved families and the local community,” she added.
“We are working hard to support the local community and to identify offenders. There will be information out there that will help us to put a stop to this unacceptable behaviour.”
Teenager charged in relation to vandalism of bookmakers attack memorial
By Claudia Savage, Belfast News Letter, November 21st, 2026
A teenager has been charged in relation to the vandalism of a memorial for victims of a UDA gun attack in Belfast.
The plaque for victims of the Sean Graham Bookmakers attack on the Ormeau Road in 1992 was splattered with white paint in the early hours of Friday.
Five Catholics were killed in the loyalist gun attack and another seven people were injured.
On Saturday police investigating a hate crime involving criminal damage in the lower Ormeau area of South Belfast charged a man to court.
The 18-year-old has been charged with offences including criminal damage and is expected to appear before Belfast Magistrates’ Court on Friday 1December 18.
Council probing fundraiser for NI trio convicted of vicious sectarian assault on Celtic fan
ADRIAN RUTHERFORD and ABDULLAH SABRI, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
FOOTBALL EVENT HELD ON LAND OWNED BY BELFAST CITY COUNCIL
Council officials have begun an investigation into a fundraising football tournament for three Belfast men convicted over a sectarian assault after an Old Firm game.
The event was held at Inverary Playing Fields - the home of East Belfast FC - last Sunday.
The playing fields are owned by the city council.
Last month, three men were jailed for attacking a Celtic fan following a Scottish Cup clash at Rangers' Ibrox Stadium on March 8.
Celtic won the game on penalties after a 0-0 draw, but the match was marred by violence, with fans clashing on the pitch.
Trouble continued outside the ground, leading to the assault on Bruce Craik.
Scott Dragsness (55), Andrew Graham (21) and Ben Stanex (24) were convicted of the attack, which left the 48-year-old with a bleed on the brain.
Stanex, from Clarawood Park in Belfast; Graham, of Moatview Park in Dundonald, and Dragsness, from Avoniel Road in Belfast, all pleaded guilty at Glasgow Sheriff Court.
A court heard Mr Craik was ushering fellow fans onto a supporters' bus when he was rounded upon by a rival mob including the trio.
The group hurled a sectarian slur at Mr Craik before he was punched by Stanex, who then repeatedly stamped on his head. Dragsness and Graham then joined in and kicked Mr Craik to the body.
The stricken victim was left unconscious and was later found to have suffered a bleed to the brain.
Stanex and Graham were each jailed for one year. Dragsness received an 18-month sentence.
A fundraising event for the men was held last weekend.
Social media posts by the Con Club Loyal East Belfast Rangers Supporters' Club advertised the tournament and said it was for the “East Belfast Three”.
“This day is about much more than football,” a post said. “It's about standing shoulder to shoulder with three of our own and helping families who continue to face unimaginable pressure.”
However, the incident was raised at a meeting of Belfast City Council's Strategic Policy and Resources Committee yesterday morning.
A council spokesperson said: “The council was not involved in organising the event, which was in support of three men convicted and jailed in Scotland in connection to a serious assault following a Celtic-Rangers game.
No support or funds
“The council did not fund or give any support to this event.
“At this morning's meeting of the Strategic Policy and Resources Committee, it was agreed that further information would be provided to elected members in due course. The committee also decided that an apology be issued for this happening on our land and for any hurt caused.
“This decision is still subject to ratification at the next full meeting of council on Tuesday, December 1.”
Sinn Féin councillor Natasha Brennan said there cannot be a repeat of what happened.
She said: “I proposed that Belfast City Council issue a formal apology for its role in allowing this event to proceed, given the serious reputational damage it has caused to the council. I am pleased that this proposal was successful, despite the DUP voting against an apology.
“Our thoughts remain firmly with the victim and their family, who have suffered enormously as a result of this horrific sectarian assault on this Celtic fan who was simply boarding a bus after a game against Rangers in March.
“Sinn Féin expects a full and transparent investigation into how this event was approved and why it was not stopped from taking place on council property.
“We will be seeking assurances that the council's policies and procedures are reviewed and strengthened to ensure that events of this nature cannot happen again.”
While the lands are owned by the council, Inverary Park is the home ground of East Belfast FC.
The club's legal adviser Jamie Bryson argued that the fundraiser was “lawfully and properly facilitated”, and claimed “the incessant attacks on East Belfast FC are politically motivated”.
Mr Bryson added that “the club will robustly defend itself” against the “latest sectarian witch hunt”.
In a statement, the Con Club expressed “its absolute disgust and outrage at the allegations, insinuations and comments directed towards our club by certain Belfast City councillors”.
It said: “Let us be absolutely clear and leave absolutely no room for misunderstanding. This was about raising money to help families meet costs during an extremely difficult time. Nothing more. Nothing less.
“It was not about promoting disorder, encouraging violence, endorsing criminality or supporting trouble of any description. Any attempt to portray it otherwise is something we categorically reject.
“Our club does not condone violence, intimidation, disorder or unlawful behaviour in any form, and we strongly object to any suggestion to the contrary. Helping families should never be twisted into an allegation of supporting wrongdoing.
“We find it utterly disgraceful that certain elected representatives have made allegations which, in our view, unfairly attack the reputation of our club, its members and those who were simply trying to provide financial assistance to families.”
“There is a fundamental difference between providing financial support to families facing difficult circumstances and endorsing the actions or behaviour of any individual. That distinction must be recognised.
“Supporting families is not supporting violence. Helping those facing financial hardship is not endorsing criminality. And no amount of political commentary will change those facts.”
Elections come, elections go, but little change for North’s health service
MARK HENNESSY, Irish Times, Ireland and Britain Editor, November 21st, 2026
Belfast doctor Alan Stout, chair of the British Medical Association’s NI council, says the North’s health service has gone backwards over the past decade
From Alan Stout’s office in the Arches Medical Centre, the Belfast doctor can see the famous Samson and Goliath cranes of the old Harland & Wolff shipbuilding yard in east Belfast, which created much of the city’s fortunes.
For more than a century, thousands of mostly Protestant workers left terraced housing on the Lower Newtownards Road and surrounding districts to work inside its gates.
The shipyard left its toll.
“There would have been a lot of respiratory illnesses. When I started, back in 2001, we would’ve had quite a number of patients with asbestosis,” says Stout, referring to the chronic lung disease caused by inhaling asbestos fibres over a long period of time.
“We don’t have that many of those patients now. People unfortunately pass away, far too early.”
Stout, who is chair of the British Medical Association’s Northern Ireland council, remembers a much-liked patient bringing old photographs of “snowball” fights in the yards.
“But it wasn’t snow. It was handfuls of asbestos. They’d hurl them during breaks – didn’t know the dangers,” he says.
If the health legacy left by the shipyards is receding into history, there are plenty of others.
“Walk out the front door here and turn right and you end up in some of the most deprived parts of Northern Ireland,” he says.
“Turn left, and you go straight up to Ballyhackamore. It’s a few miles. You could walk between them. Yet there is a gap of seven or eight years of life, and certainly 10 years of healthy life, between them.”
The state of the health of the population on both parts of the island will come under the microscope on Monday, with the publication of the latest research report from the Dublin-based Economic and Social Research Institute.
The detailed research into health inequalities across the island and the lifestyles that can cause or worsen some of those conditions has been funded by the Irish Government’s Shared Island Unit.
‘Entrenched inequalities’
It will show that the majority of Northern Ireland’s health inequalities are caused by “deep-seated structural disadvantage” that is embedded into Northern Ireland’s society.
The inequalities will not be remedied solely by urging people to eat better or drink or smoke less but requires action to remove “entrenched systemic inequalities”, the report will say.
The research shows that people in better-off districts north and south of the Border drink more than poorer counterparts, but alcohol causes more damage to the poor because they binge drink.
Much of the debate about health services in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland centres on the existence of the National Health Service north of the Border in contrast to the medical card and pay-as-you-go model in the South.
For Stout, the argument about the differences between the two misses the point.
“The starkest differences are not about what conditions people present with, but when they present,” he says, emphasising the “when”.
Pointing towards the wealthier end of his district, he says: “This is the absolute travesty of Northern Ireland healthcare. If somebody comes from that direction, they’ll say: ‘I can either pay’ or ‘I’ve got health insurance’.”
“Then we can get them seen quickly by a consultant or whatever. But if they come from the other side, closer to the city, then they have no chance of paying and no chance of being seen.”
For years, Stout has argued trenchantly that Northern Ireland’s health services suffer not from a lack of reform plans, but from a lack of political willingness to enforce the plans already in existence.
A 2016 plan led by Rafael Bengoa, the Spanish doctor and health policy expert who worked for the World Health Organisation, was intended to change healthcare in Northern Ireland and correctly identified the main issues: the need for a smaller number of better hospitals, stronger primary care and more and better treatment delivered locally.
Instead of Stormont implementing the Bengoa report, Northern Ireland has gone backwards, he says, quoting figures from memory.
“In the 10 years since Bengoa, the numbers on waiting lists have gone from 225,000 to 504,000,” says Stout.
“The numbers waiting over 52 weeks have gone from 30,000 to 270,000. The numbers waiting over 12 hours in emergency departments every year have gone from 3,900 to 139,100.
“That’s an astonishing figure, and the harm that’s been caused with that. The number of emergency patients seen and discharged within four hours has fallen from 76 per cent to just 43 per cent.”
Stout argues that “a forced helplessness” has been created.
“It’s astonishing when I say to a patient with neurology symptoms that I’ll refer them to a neurologist, but it could be seven years before they see one, that they’ll just shrug their shoulders and go: ‘Oh, well.’”
‘We don’t prioritise well’
Too often, Stout has heard Stormont politicians of all hues lay the blame for Northern Ireland’s struggling health service at London’s door and for the failure of the UK treasury to properly to fund it.
The differences between the quality of the National Health Service seen in Northern Ireland compared with England, Scotland and Wales are raised not infrequently at British Medical Association meetings, he says.
“Our GB colleagues say to us that if what was happening here was happening in London, Manchester or Liverpool, they would be protesting on the streets. They just wouldn’t accept it,” he says.
Emergency actions, especially in England, follow when the number of people waiting for more than 12 months exceeds acceptable limits.
“That becomes a catastrophe and they invest heavily,” he says. “Here, we go from 30,000 to 270,000 waiting over 52 weeks, and nothing happens. Politicians just say: it’s Westminster’s fault, and it’s the treasury’s fault, that they don’t give us enough money.”
For Stout, that is not good enough.
“The challenge here is not just about money. Number one, we have to understand how much money we have, how much resource we have. I’m not sure we do,” he says.
“Number two, we have got to make sure that what money we have, we spend as well and efficiently as possible. And that includes prioritisation. Because we don’t prioritise well, either.”
Stormont’s failure to agree multiannual priorities makes long-term health planning that could tackle deep-seated inequalities impossible, but now it is unable even to agree a yearly budget.
Just months from next May’s Stormont elections, Stout is despondent that anything will change.
“Nobody can lose; the figures change a bit,” he says, “but everybody who wants still gets into government. Nothing changes.”
Fearless first female leader of a political party in north
ANNE DICKSON - OBITUARY
Irish News, November 21st, 2026
ANNE Dickson, who has died aged 98, made history in 1976 when she became the first woman to lead a mainstream political party in Northern Ireland.
The moderate unionist, who was also the only female MP in the last Stormont parliament, supported the power-sharing government led by Brian Faulkner and succeeded him as leader of the Unionist Party NI.
She went on to serve as the first chair of the General Consumer Council and was remembered at her funeral for her fearlessness, generosity and irrepressible sense of fun.
Born Anne Letitia McCance in London in 1928, she grew up as a much-loved only child in Knocknagoney, east Belfast.
After Richmond Lodge School, where she became an accomplished pianist and violinist, she briefly worked at the Ulster Bank head office, now the Merchant Hotel.
Anne met her future husband, Jim Dickson, when he was best man and she was chief bridesmaid at a wedding. They married in 1951 and had four children, Johnnie, Janet, Kerry and Diana.
Politics was never a conscious career choice. Rather, Anne simply believed in helping others.
She became involved in the Ulster Unionist Party, served on Newtownabbey Urban District Council, and was elected to represent Carrick in the old Stormont House of Commons in 1969 – the only woman among 52 MPs.
At a tumultuous time in politics, she was a supporter of prime minister Terence O’Neill’s reforms.
Standing up to misogynists and bigots, she spoke out about discrimination in employment and housing and received death threats from both the UVF and IRA, and her home was pipe-bombed by loyalists in 1970.
When Stormont held its last sitting in March 1972, she warned that it might be the final time it adjourned as a functioning parliament.
Having already broken with the Ulster Unionist Party, Anne was elected to the 1973 Assembly as an independent unionist for South Antrim.
Following the collapse of the Sunningdale power-sharing executive, she joined Faulkner’s Unionist Party of Northern Ireland and was elected to the Constitutional Convention in 1975. The party dissolved in 1981.
Her daughter Diana remembered a mother whose crowded diary meant meals were rarely uninterrupted and evenings were filled with meetings and public engagements.
One day, while shopping as a teenager in Robinson & Cleaver’s Bel-fast store, she heard Anne’s familiar voice through a loudspeaker.
Looking outside, she discovered her addressing a crowd at City Hall in support of better pay and working conditions for nurses.
But for all the demands of public life, family life was precious too.
Each summer Anne and Jim took their children on month-long camping adventures across Europe, trips which taught them to appreciate other cultures.
“ Standing up to misogynists and bigots, she spoke out about discrimination in employment and housing and received death threats from both the UVF and IRA, and her home was pipe-bombed by loyalists in 1970
Anne also adored animals, owning four successive German Shepherds. She once confessed, half-joking, that she preferred animals to people, believing them more reliable.
She served as the first chair of the General Consumer Council for Northern Ireland from 1985 to 1990.
Appointed CBE in 1990, she continued giving her time on public bodies, including as a lay member of the Law Society, until retiring in her mid-eighties.
Retirement meant more time to read, to go to concerts, the theatre or travel to warmer climates – no longer camping, but still enjoying life.
Predeceased by her husband Jim and children Johnnie and Kerry, Anne Dickson is survived by her daughters Janet and Diana.
In a eulogy at her funeral service at St Patrick’s Church, Jordanstown on November 13, Diana said they would miss her wise words, advice and love – and the certainty that there was “never a dull moment” in her company.
Independent Orange Order's criticism of King belongs in 17th century
ALF McCREARY, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
King Charles has been criticised severely by the Grand Master of the Independent Loyal Orange Lodge Institution for his remarks this week to the Church of England General Synod in London.
In his first address to the Synod as King and Supreme Governor of the Church of England, Charles spoke about his own deep Christian faith, and outlined his vision for the Church's public role.
He said: “At a time when our society can feel divided, it is all the more important that the Church of England continues to extend its ministry among all the people of this country.
“The church protects not just the Christian faith of all of us gathered in this room, but the very space for faith itself — of every belief — within our whole society and national discourse.”
This was nothing new, because the King has long regarded his role as “defender of the faiths”, and has made this clear many times.
Despite this, his remarks have resulted in extraordinary comments from Phil Moffatt, who has accused him of speaking “utter nonsense”.
This shows disrespect to the monarch to the point of rudeness.
He accuses the King of attempting “to dilute the pledge of office and to dismiss the oath which he made before the nation at his coronation… the King's pledge to the nation was to defend the Protestant Reformed faith by law”.
Mr Moffatt further criticises him in language that is rarely heard from anyone in the Orange Orders when speaking about the monarch, to whom they generally pledge their loyalty.
“Sadly a lack of wisdom and spiritual insight by the King has resulted in him being blown about with every wind and doctrine.
“He cannot be the defender of all faiths, many of which do not embrace Biblical truth.”
These comments belong to the 17th century, and not to the modern world of inclusive faiths and cultures.
They also show how far Mr Moffatt and his Independent Orange Institution is out of step with the times.
Instead of offering friendship and respect for people from other backgrounds, this theological version of 'Not an inch' and of 'No surrender' simply puts people off religion and the Orange Orders in general.
It also does great harm to the image of Orangeism, just like the Portadown Lodge, which insisted on its right to march down Garvaghy Road, having been granted legal permission to do so.
Sadly the lodge was badly advised and blindly unable to figure out for itself that it would have won the moral high ground by deciding to march back on a different route, in the interests of peace-keeping and of improving community relations.
No doubt there are some decent Orange and Independent Orange members in the ranks at large, as well as the many hardline exponents of 'No surrender' but tragically they are all blinkered and still marching into the past.
The old slogans, and the sashes their fathers wore, show no attempt to adapt to the real world in which we all live today.
It is time for them to wise up.
Public entitled to know how their money has been spent, says MLA
GABRIELLE SWAN, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
REFURBISHING OF FIRST AND DEPUTY FIRST MINISTER'S OFFICE COST £50K
The cost of refurbishment work at the First and deputy First Minister's offices was more than £50,000, it has been revealed.
Repair works included new curtains, lighting improvements and replacement floor coverings.
The £51,119.57 bill was revealed by the Assembly Commission after questions from the TUV MLA Timothy Gaston.
He said The Executive Office had refused to release photographs of the work.
The bill comes at a time when many public services are facing cutbacks.
This week it was announced that late-night train services in Northern Ireland are to be reduced and some fare discounts are to be lowered as part of new cost-cutting measures at Translink.
The Belfast Telegraph also reported that financial pressures at the Department for the Economy have even led to officials taking tea and coffee off the menu for some guests.
Mr Gaston questioned the extent of works carried out within all ministerial offices in Parliament Buildings during the current Assembly mandate, with the commission confirming that repairs were carried out to rooms used by Michelle O'Neill and Emma Little-Pengelly.
Mr Gaston said that while he recognised the historical significance of the building, “the public is entitled to know how its money has been spent”.
Refurbishment and redecoration
The Assembly Commission said: “During the 2022-2027 Assembly mandate, refurbishment and redecoration works were undertaken within the First Minister's and Deputy First Minister's offices.
“These works included internal redecoration, replacement of floor coverings, installation or replacement of curtains and blinds, lighting improvements and associated electrical alterations.
“Lighting upgrades were also undertaken within other ministerial offices.”
The spokesperson said it was part of the commission's “ongoing responsibility to maintain Parliament Buildings and the accommodation provided within it”.
“The works were carried out to address normal wear and tear, maintain the condition and appearance of the accommodation, improve functionality and ensure the offices remained fit for purpose and suitable for official business,” they added.
“Decoration works within the Office of the Leader of the Opposition were undertaken prior to occupation, as the accommodation had previously been used as a meeting room and required preparation for its intended use as office accommodation.
“The Assembly Commission has previously confirmed that the total cost of refurbishment and redecoration works undertaken within the Deputy First Minister's offices during the 2022-2027 Assembly mandate was £28,816.
“The cost of refurbishment works undertaken within the First Minister's offices as part of the same overall project was £22,303.57.”
A breakdown of the spending was not released, with the commission stating that “associated pricing information is commercially sensitive”.
Mr Gaston said The Executive Office should release photographs of the work.
“The public should now be able to see what was done and how their money was spent, yet for months the Executive Office have refused to release photographs,” he said.
“While the headline figures have been disclosed, the Commission has declined to provide a breakdown of materials, contractor charges or staff time, citing commercial sensitivity. I want to know why publishing the costs of completed work would prejudice future procurement.
“Looking after a historic building is important. So is scrutiny of public spending.”
Is Lough Neagh drinking water safe? New book exposes NI Water sewage scandal
TAMPERING WITH WATER TESTS, MASSAGING FIGURES AND PRESSURE NOT TO TELL THE PUBLIC: INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALIST'S BOOK SETS OUT SCALE OF SCANDAL
SAM McBRIDE, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
As Lough Neagh has died, NI Water has insisted that drinking water drawn from the polluted lough remains safe — but a new book raises disturbing questions about whether we can trust what we're being told.
Three years ago, the lough's pollution became unmistakable when massive 'blue-green algae' blooms — cyanobacteria — turned the water luminescent green.
The foul-smelling bacteria, producing toxins capable of killing animals as big as horses, have triggered a collapse in the lough's ecosystem, and ended the historic eel fishing on the vast inland sea which inspired Seamus Heaney.
Some 40pc of Northern Ireland's drinking water comes from Lough Neagh, yet we also pour raw sewage into the lough — along with supposedly treated sewage.
Troubled Waters, a disturbing new book by investigative journalist Tommy Greene, exposes how Stormont is at the heart of this scandal and how it is getting worse.
The book's most serious allegation is that NI Water has rigged the testing system for what it calls 'treated' sewage discharges.
Various sources alleged to Greene that “a culture of obscuring and misleading presentation of statistics was introduced at NI Water more than 15 years ago”.
NI Water has boasted that it has “achieved the best ever drinking water quality and wastewater compliance” and “near record levels of wastewater compliance”.
‘Built on a lie’
The book says that “variations on these claims were trotted out by senior figures…however, there was a problem with this narrative: it was largely 'built on a lie', as one well-placed source underlined.”
He says that as the crisis grew, insiders say the Department for Infrastructure (DfI) kept telling NI Water: “Sure, we wouldn't want to see a situation like the one going on in England currently” — a reference to publicity over British sewage spills and wastewater pollution, implying that Northern Ireland's position was better.
This, he said, was “absurd and fundamentally dishonest to those with any awareness of NI Water's data collection practices”.
He quotes a source saying that DfI, which oversees NI Water, was “living in a bubble”, where it was “massaging the figures and neutering any internal opposition”, with NI Water split between those willing to “toe this line” and those who believed they'd a duty as public servants to “level with the public”.
Sources told Greene that NI Water adopted a 'compliance is king' culture, but this involved a stance which “is less a culture of actually achieving greater compliance in wastewater treatment than one of providing the impression that this is the case… fiddling with wastewater statistics and testing is allegedly rife within the agency”.
He quotes one well-placed source saying: “It's a kind of corruption that goes right to the top of government” and sets out how “one of the most obvious and glaring ways in which the official statistics for the quality of water released into our rivers have been distorted is through the way samples are tested”.
Polluters protected
Britain has long had unannounced tests on wastewater plant discharges. Stormont refuses to do this and instead largely gives warning to NI Water when inspectors are coming.
That, as senior NI Water and NI Environment Agency (NIEA) officials once euphemistically said, allows them to “get their house in order”.
As a result, insiders have told Greene that samples currently “pass on the days they're tested but fail on the rest”, with the prevailing attitude allegedly being that “whatever happens, it shall pass on testing day.”
Greene notes that during the late 2000s, NI Water's reported compliance levels rose dramatically. What insiders allege to him is at least partially substantiated by limited public data on the small number of unannounced tests.
Between 2021 and 2024, when NI Water had warning of tests, they showed high compliance. Greene notes that the reported figures “were almost identical year on year - 93.75pc in 2021 and 2022, 93.72pc for 2023 and 2024 — which crucially brought them just above its performance target of 93pc.
However, those years' limited unannounced tests were closer to 80pc compliance — 86.25pc for 2021, 82.5pc in 2022, 86.61pc in 2023 and 83.68pc in 2024 — meaning around a fifth of unannounced wastewater samples didn't meet NI Water's legal requirements.
The author says he has been told that if other polluting discharges were taken into account, as is due to happen by 2028, more than half of NI Water's biggest treatment works, serving populations of 250 or higher, would fail to achieve basic compliance standards, suggesting that some plants can only process around half of their current sewage.
Is the water safe?
This raises the most troubling question: If we can't trust NI Water in this area of testing, can we trust them when they've repeatedly insisted the water is safe to drink, even as reports of discoloured and malodourous tap water grow?
When the Lough Neagh scandal erupted in 2023, a press release from Stormont's Department for Agriculture, the Environment, and Rural Affairs (DAERA) cited drinking water test results with a 99.9pc compliance rate.
While sewage is the second-greatest source of pollution entering the lough, the biggest problem is from agriculture.
Stormont's 2013 'Going for Growth' strategy turbocharged pollution by using public money to incentivise factory farming.
Greene reveals ministerial correspondence which refers to the 'Moy Park Strategic Planning Project' to help the enormous poultry processor's expansion. It included a 'dedicated project team' within government to, in the words of one document, “process an anticipated influx of planning applications for poultry houses by Moy Park”.
Yet when Greene asked DAERA about this, it said it held no records about the unit's creation, while DfI said any documents it held would likely have been destroyed.
55% increase in phosphorus
Moy Park supplies a third of UK supermarket chicken, with Tesco and Sainsbury's among its customers.
The company was far from the only beneficiary of 'Going for Growth' but Greene charts how in the decade following that strategy there was a 55pc increase in levels of phosphorus, a key agent for cyanobacteria growth, in waterways.
The five years prior to that period had involved a continuing downward trend in both nitrate and phosphorus levels in freshwaters, showing that there was no inevitability to what happened.
One farmer told him that many farmers are now frustrated that the finger is being pointed at them when they just did what government and industry bosses urged.
Moy Park said that there were “a number of drivers behind the algae blooms on Lough Neagh” and “it is a complex issue not specifically linked to any one sector”. The company — which is owned by vast US multinational Pilgrim's, which in turn is owned by behemoth Brazilian meatpacker JBS — added that “the poultry industry is highly regulated with strict limits set for wastewater quality at all NI facilities” and it was working to “further improve” discharges from its abattoirs.
As well as animal excrement being spread on land which runs into waterways — or being deliberately poured into watercourses — Greene reveals that human excrement has been spread in the lough's catchment.
This 'land-spreading' sees farmers paid to spread processed human sewage - or 'sew¬age sludge' — on their land as a cheap fertiliser. More than 53,000 tonnes of it have been spread in Northern Ireland since 2015 as part of a Public Private Partnership between NI Water and Glen Water Ltd.
Greene sets out a chasm between politicians' rhetoric and behaviour. Despite Lough Neagh supposedly being one of this Executive's top priorities, only one minister would speak to him — and DAERA minister Andrew Muir would only give him a 15-minute video interview.
He said Muir's press officers told him several areas were off-limits — even as they were contacting YouTubers and social media influencers over Lough Neagh.
Inspectors are hopelessly ill-equipped to catch law-breaking — and when polluters are caught, fines are derisory.
DAERA says two staff are required to lead a farm inspection for “health and safety reasons”. There had been 10 staff available to lead inspections in 2014, the year after Going for Growth began. A decade on, there were just six lead inspectors and four in training.
One inspector for every 4,333 farms
By June 2024, there were more than 26,000 farms in Northern Ireland, meaning there was one inspection team for every 4,333 farms.
While Greene's book exposes this to the public, he makes clear that Stormont has known this for years, but consciously failed to act.
Weeks before the 2024 general election, one of NI Water's key figures, Gary Curran, gave an interview to the BBC in which he set out how bad the health of Belfast Lough was becoming.
Greene says Curran was then allegedly “slapped down” by senior DfI figures, acting under instructions from the then minister, John O'Dowd. He quotes a source who said Curran's interview had run contrary to the 'nothing to see here' message being enforced from O'Dowd's office.
Sinn Féin has run DfI for longer than any other party since the establishment of NI Water in 2007.
A planned £1.4 billion investment in NI Water's waste-processing facilities between 2021 and 2033 was “gutted” during the last Stormont collapse, falling to less than £350m even as inflation meant costs soared.
O'Dowd rubber-stamped this cut in 2024, despite NI Water boss Sara Venning publicly warning MLAs that “by 2030 large parts of Northern Ireland will be unable to connect new customer demand for wastewater services for homes, public buildings and businesses.”
Greene says that a 2024 presentation informed O'Dowd that his Upper Bann constituency already had “bad/poor” water quality and another slide contained red text from the NIEA which starkly warned: “This infrastructure is presenting a very real risk to both public health and the environment and continued failure to improve this infrastructure will result in continued deterioration of the water quality and will be in breach of regulatory requirements.”
By March 2025, an investigation team from the Office of Environmental Protection — a UK-wide watchdog — told top NI Water figures that wastewater standards and pressures were worse in Northern Ireland than anywhere in Britain.
When the allegations of fiddling with testing were put to NI Water by this newspaper, it did not dispute them.
Instead, it said that independent reports “consistently highlighted the impact of sustained underinvestment in wastewater infrastructure on environmental performance, capacity, new connections, and economic development”.
It said the NIEA sets the regulatory framework, adding: “We welcome greater transparency and scrutiny so there is a fuller picture of the performance of our wastewater system and where improvements and investment are required.”
In denial
DfI said it “does not recognise or accept the scenarios presented, or the basis of the assertions made by the author, in the extract provided”.
It said a forensic audit is under way in NI Water, that it gives the utility about half a billion pounds a year, and that in previous years NI Water was “fully funded”.
DfI said Minister Liz Kimmins is introducing 'developer contributions, changing the law on sustainable drainage, and arguing for more money.'
When decisions were made as to where the inadequate funding for upgrades should be allocated, Greene found that the biggest upgrade happened to help Moy Park.
He says a key reason for the prioritisation of the £44m Dungannon works over greater problems at far bigger wastewater plants was spelt out in an internal NI Water document: “Major impact on expansion plans of Moy Park.”
The company told him that this was a matter for NI Water and it had no direct role in determining what happened.
Greene says he has written confirmation from NI Water officials that regular meetings have taken place between their organisation and leading Moy Park figures — but with no records taken of these discussions.
Looking to the future, Greene paints a gloomy picture. Comparable cyanobacteria pollution in other parts of the world has led authorities to warn hundreds of thousands of people not to drink their tap water for part of the year.
While arguing that the situation can be drastically improved, Greene warns bleakly: “It is also important to be clear that some things have been irretrievably lost. A number of scientists have underlined that it will be nearly impossible for the lough to return to the state it was in during the late 1980s or early 1990s. Some species are unlikely ever to return, while a considerable number stand on the brink of outright disappearance or extinction.”
Troubled Waters is published by Merrion Press
Public entitled to know how their money has been spent, says MLA
GABRIELLE SWAN, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
REFURBISHING OF FIRST AND DEPUTY FIRST MINISTER'S OFFICE COST £50K
The cost of refurbishment work at the First and deputy First Minister's offices was more than £50,000, it has been revealed.
Repair works included new curtains, lighting improvements and replacement floor coverings.
The £51,119.57 bill was revealed by the Assembly Commission after questions from the TUV MLA Timothy Gaston.
He said The Executive Office had refused to release photographs of the work.
The bill comes at a time when many public services are facing cutbacks.
This week it was announced that late-night train services in Northern Ireland are to be reduced and some fare discounts are to be lowered as part of new cost-cutting measures at Translink.
The Belfast Telegraph also reported that financial pressures at the Department for the Economy have even led to officials taking tea and coffee off the menu for some guests.
Mr Gaston questioned the extent of works carried out within all ministerial offices in Parliament Buildings during the current Assembly mandate, with the commission confirming that repairs were carried out to rooms used by Michelle O'Neill and Emma Little-Pengelly.
Mr Gaston said that while he recognised the historical significance of the building, “the public is entitled to know how its money has been spent”.
Refurbishment and redecoration
The Assembly Commission said: “During the 2022-2027 Assembly mandate, refurbishment and redecoration works were undertaken within the First Minister's and Deputy First Minister's offices.
“These works included internal redecoration, replacement of floor coverings, installation or replacement of curtains and blinds, lighting improvements and associated electrical alterations.
“Lighting upgrades were also undertaken within other ministerial offices.”
The spokesperson said it was part of the commission's “ongoing responsibility to maintain Parliament Buildings and the accommodation provided within it”.
“The works were carried out to address normal wear and tear, maintain the condition and appearance of the accommodation, improve functionality and ensure the offices remained fit for purpose and suitable for official business,” they added.
“Decoration works within the Office of the Leader of the Opposition were undertaken prior to occupation, as the accommodation had previously been used as a meeting room and required preparation for its intended use as office accommodation.
“The Assembly Commission has previously confirmed that the total cost of refurbishment and redecoration works undertaken within the Deputy First Minister's offices during the 2022-2027 Assembly mandate was £28,816.
“The cost of refurbishment works undertaken within the First Minister's offices as part of the same overall project was £22,303.57.”
A breakdown of the spending was not released, with the commission stating that “associated pricing information is commercially sensitive”.
Mr Gaston said The Executive Office should release photographs of the work.
“The public should now be able to see what was done and how their money was spent, yet for months the Executive Office have refused to release photographs,” he said.
“While the headline figures have been disclosed, the Commission has declined to provide a breakdown of materials, contractor charges or staff time, citing commercial sensitivity. I want to know why publishing the costs of completed work would prejudice future procurement.
“Looking after a historic building is important. So is scrutiny of public spending.”
The new UK-EU deal will make it easier for NI businesses to operate - Bryant
KYLE FRAZER and CLAUDIA SAVAGE, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
SECRETARY OF STATE VISITS BELFAST WHERE FLORIST TELLS HIM OF TRADING DIFFICULTIES FOLLOWING BREXIT
A Northern Ireland florist has told the Secretary of State he hopes a new deal between the UK and the EU aimed at agri-food imports will “relieve” the issues they have faced with importing goods.
Gary Connolly, owner of Memento flower shop on the Ormeau Road, spoke to Sir Chris Bryant during a visit to south Belfast and explained the trading difficulties he has experienced as a small retailer.
The meeting yesterday came as Prime Minister Andy Burnham outlined plans for closer alignment between Brussels with EU chiefs, Ursula von der Leyen and Antonio Costa.
Mr Connolly said businesses like his had struggled following Brexit and in particular since the introduction of the Windsor Framework.
He said: “The ability to trade with GB or purchase from GB came with custom costs, came with aggro, came with us, the purchaser, educating the supplier on what the process is, what the trusted trader scheme is, what the ERI scheme is, and not even mention UKIMS [UK internal market scheme] — it's just another ball game altogether.
“So, we've found it very difficult. I've been in touch with my local MPs on many occasions, many times in the early hours of the morning, after spending hours placing orders with suppliers from GB, only to turn around and have them cancelled.
“So, as a small business owner, to lose that time, that's why you find yourself working at four or five in the morning, because you're spending time doing your ordering, and then the thing's just cancelled, so all of your plans for that stock is now gone.
“I'm really hoping that what has been agreed and what the Prime Minister has agreed with the EU will actually relieve some of the issues we're having.”
Speaking on the Ormeau Road, Sir Chris said flowers were just one example of something from Brexit which now involves “a vast amount of complicated paperwork” before confirming “we're getting rid of virtually all of that”.
Transformational
“We're going to make it much easier for people to import flowers — 85pc of all flowers sold in the UK come either from or through the Netherlands, so this will be transformational for that,” he said.
He added that the previous deal that was arranged under former Conservative Prime Minister Boris Johnson was “terrible”.
“Northern Ireland has grown economically faster than the rest of the UK under Brexit. Northern Ireland didn't vote for Brexit, of course,” Sir Chris added.
Speaking in Brussels, the Prime Minister said the new deal will add up to £17bn to the economy, with Treasury analysts forecasting a 0.5pc growth to GDP by 2040.
He said it was “a good day for Britain and a good day for Europe”.
The Prime Minister said the new deal would “draw a line on a decade of drift and division” and that the next decade would be “more hopeful”.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said the deal was a “turning point”.
Reacting to the new deal, DUP leader Gavin Robinson said his party would welcome any moves towards dismantling the Irish Sea border produced by the Windsor Framework.
The East Belfast MP added: “Reducing barriers is not the same as removing them. The border created by the Windsor Framework must be totally dismantled.
“Northern Ireland should not be treated as a third country when trading with the rest of the UK.”
He added that the Government needs to “demonstrate as much serious intent to restoring the integrity of the UK internal market as it does to improve access to the European market”.
Mixed reactions
UUP MLA Dr Steve Aiken gave a guarded welcome to the deal.
“We believe the new partnership will supplant the frosty relationship the UK has had with Brussels over the last decade,” he said.
“Whether these changes will help dismantle the Irish Sea border or strengthen the much-weakened UK internal market remains to be seen, but if negotiations are concluded in good faith, this is something we can all welcome.”
TUV leader Jim Allister said Mr Burnham was moving to “reverse Brexit”.
“He has surrendered the whole UK to be a rule taker on food laws we don't make and can't change.
“If food checks are being removed, then when will the border posts — built for that purpose — be removed?”
Agriculture and Environment Minister Andrew Muir said the news was “a positive step in the right direction” but urged Mr Burnham to go further.
“Whilst it won't solve all issues caused by Brexit, the final deal is a positive step. It is good news for consumers, businesses and farmers.
“It is beyond a doubt that Brexit has been a failed experiment. The change in mood music from the Prime Minister is welcome, but I would urge him to use this summit as a springboard to go further in strengthening ties with the EU.
“We must leave the isolationism of Brexit behind.”
SDLP MLA Matthew O'Toole said the deal was “a step towards undoing the damage of Brexit”.
“Brexit inflicted profound damage on our economy. It created barriers where there had been none, increased costs and bureaucracy for businesses and left Northern Ireland dealing with the consequences of a project that reflected neither the will of our people nor our economic interests,” he said.
“Today's agreement is a welcome recognition of something the SDLP has been saying for years — Northern Ireland's economic interests are best served by the closest possible relationship with our biggest and nearest trading partner, the European Union.”
Striking resident doctors warn low pay is fuelling health service staffing crisis
CLAUDIA SAVAGE, Belfast Telegraph, November 21st, 2026
LABOUR WITHDRAWAL TO BE FOLLOWED BY SPECIALISTS AND CONSULTANTS TAKING ACTION ON MONDAY
Low pay for young doctors in Northern Ireland is having a “massive impact” on the health service, a union leader has warned as resident doctors undertook a 24-hour strike.
Dr Steven Montgomery, chairman of the British Medical Association (BMA) Northern Ireland resident doctors committee, warned there would be “effects felt” for the general public in the form of cancelled appointments and surgeries.
The 24-hour walkout from 7am on Friday until 7am on Saturday saw resident doctors withdraw their labour from hospitals and GP surgeries.
The action will be followed by specialist and consultant doctors in the region striking on Monday.
It is the second round of strike action relating to the demand for full pay restoration, after a 24-hour walkout was also held by doctors in June this year.
Speaking at a picket line outside the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast, Dr Montgomery outlined that resident doctors have faced a 20pc reduction in pay since 2018.
“That's having a massive impact on the health service here in Northern Ireland, on the staff here in Northern Ireland, and the sort of morale of people here in Northern Ireland,” he said.
“We're seeing waiting lists grow exponentially, we're seeing doctors leaving to work elsewhere and what really is going to fix most of this is retaining the staff we have here and that all starts with pay.
“We need to make sure doctors here in Northern Ireland are paid similarly to their colleagues doing the same job very close by.”
He said the problems people in the region encounter in the health service, such as being placed on waiting lists or long A&E wait times, “all boils down to us not having enough staff here to run the services they want”.
“The massive fix for that is going to be keeping the staff we have here, and that all starts with pay, we need to pay doctors what they're worth,” he said.
Dr Montgomery said people would feel the impact of resident doctors withdrawing their labour, and he feels “genuinely sorry” that is the case.
“We don't want to be here, no doctor wants to be on the picket line, no doctor wants to be striking,” he said.
“There will be appointments cancelled, there will be surgeries cancelled, however, there will be emergency care provided by consultants and specialist doctors throughout the day, and there is a process that the trusts can request extra doctors back if there is a situation that arises that needs additional staffing.
“So we're trying to do this in the safest way possible, but unfortunately, there will be some effects felt.”
Northern Ireland is without an agreed budget seven months into the current financial year, as Stormont Executive parties argue they cannot agree a package with the offer from Westminster, and Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant insisting no more money will be put on the table.
Dr Montgomery said there are no “perfect answers” about how to resolve the budget impasse but he is clear that “something needs to be fixed” in the health system in Northern Ireland.
“What we're doing today is we're raising the alarm that this is a healthcare system in crisis, and it's a staffing crisis, and we need to fix that,” he said.
“And don't get me wrong, I don't think pay is a silver bullet that's going to fix everything, but I think it's the first step in improving the health service here in Northern Ireland, and giving patients here in Northern Ireland the healthcare system they deserve.”
The union leader also said they wrote to Stormont health minister Robbie Butler over a month ago and had no reply.
“We need him to engage with us, and that lack of engagement is what has driven us here today, at the end of the day, this strike falls on the minister's feet,” he said.
Two of the resident doctors on the picket line wer, Dr Megann Crawford, working in psychiatry at Craigavon Area hospital and Dr Riya Sushil, who works in general medicine at Causeway hospital.
“It's become a bit of a problem with a brain drain,” Dr Crawford said.
“We have a lot of kids that are very smart leaving the country, going to places like Australia for a better life.
“It's left us very understaffed. They're not creating any new trainee posts to put doctors coming out of medical school into, and we're just very underpaid for the hours we work. For example, when I was a medical student, I worked in a part-time job and earned more per hour than I did as an F1, so there's just a lot of things going on that we would like to fight against, just see if we can make it a little bit easier for us.”
Speaking prior to the action commencing, Mr Butler said he is committed to implementing this year's pay award.
He added: “I have met the BMA and have outlined the financial constraints facing my department.
“My door remains open but, to be clear, going beyond the 3.5pc as recommended by the independent pay review body would have significant repercussions for nurses, teachers, police officers and indeed the entire public sector workforce. It is my intention to progress the recommended pay award as soon as possible, however, I am currently unable to do so in the absence of a sufficient budget being agreed for my department.”
Portrait of the artist as a political activist
Acclaimed Dublin-born painter and designer Robert Ballagh talks to John Manley about an artistic career spanning seven decades
John Manley, Irish Press, November 21st, 2026
ROBERT Ballagh’s first paid artistic endeavour began almost 60 years ago with an offer of “a fiver a week and all the drink you can take”. A matter of months later he was “pretending to be an artist”.
He was 25 and had recently ended a successful five-year stint playing bass with the Chessmen, one of Ireland’s leading showbands.
He remembers his father taking him to the cinema to watch Rock Around the Clock, then later going to see Bill Haley & His Comets at the capital’s Theatre Royal.
After packing in music, his prized Fender Jazz ended up slung over the shoulders of an aspiring teenage musician he knew called Philip Lynott.
“I used to watch Thin Lizzy on Top of the Pops and see my guitar,” he recalls.
“Phil was Ireland’s first rock star, though when I ran into him a few years later he told me it’d been stolen in England.”
Gigging with the Chessmen throughout Ireland gave the young Ballagh an insight into life in the north.
“It was clear things were different in the north, stuff like getting stopped late at night by the B-Specials, we didn’t have that down here,” he says.
He also remembers a relative of a band member turning up to gig in Belfast having just been beaten up for being a Catholic while buying fish and chips.
“You hear people say ‘Ah this was a great wee place until the Provos got going’ but I’m not so sure about that,” he says.
Now aged 83, he has been one of Ireland’s most acclaimed visual artists for more than 50 years.
He’s also celebrated as a graphic and theatre set designer.
Banknotes to Riverdance
His accomplishments include designing the set for Riverdance, as well as numerous plays, more than 70 postage stamps, and Irish bank notes in the days before the Euro with images of Daniel O’Connell, James Joyce, Douglas Hyde and Charles Stewart Parnell.
“Luck” has played a key role in his success, he says, insisting “you don’t make much money out of pictures”, while acknowledging that the “ancillary work” has been quite lucrative.
He rejects any suggestion that his art doesn’t demand great physical effort, describing the process of creating a painting over many months as “tedious”.
“I envy those artists who can walk into the studio with a blank canvas, and they start splashing or whatever, and they have something finished by tea time.
“I go to the studio every day for six months and work on one picture. That’s hard work.”
His portrait subjects over the years have included both historical and contemporary figures.
The former includes James Joyce, James Connolly and Oscar Wilde, while Charles Haughey, James Plunkett and John B Keane are among the latter.
Ballagh was also commissioned to paint the official portrait of two Belfast lord mayors, Sinn Féin’s Alex Maskey and Máirtín Ó Muilleoir.
Still living in inner city north Dublin with a studio a 10-minute walk away, these days his appointments are primarily of a medical rather than social nature.
His painting too reflects his own health challenges, such as Self Portrait After Heart Failure, which was unveiled late last year at Limerick’s Hunt Museum.
While age and a diagnosis of Non-Hodgkin lymphoma may have partially curtailed his activism, he retains a strong interest in politics, including north of the border.
In the 2024’s Dictionary of Irish Artists, Brian O’Doherty says “his is not so much political art as art made by an intensely political person”.
The politics of the north has manifested itself in Ballagh’s work many times over a career that in its earlier years coincided with political upheaval.
Examples include his portrait of murdered solicitor Rosemary Nelson, or his 2006 essay on the Hunger Strike entitled ‘A Profound and Historic Event’.
Féil and Gerry Adams
He’s been a supporter and guest of Féile an Phobail since its inception, having accepted a personal appeal for help from Gerry Adams in 1988.
In 2011, as set designer for River-dance, he refused to go to Israel as the musical and dance performance toured the world.
Elsewhere, he has lent his support to various political, cultural, social and community campaigns throughout Ireland.
“I’d always be sympathetic to the underdog; the people who were discriminated against, like the Palestinians today and the nationalist community in the north, I would have very naturally supported them.
“I was of course accused of supporting violence and everything. I never joined any organisation, and I never supported violence.”
Born in Ballsbridge in south Dublin, he describes his upbringing as “lower middle class”. However, he notes how his parents lived their entire married life “in a dingy basement flat” on Elgin Road.
“It only dawned on me much later that my bedroom, where I tended to spend most of my time, had no windows. Maybe that’s why I’m interested in light and colour, because I didn’t have it as a kid?”
Neighbours were both middle and working class, Catholic and Protestant.
“I feel I was lucky to grow up in that kind of environment, which I don’t think exists anymore.
“These days, everything’s ghettoised and separated.”
His parents “probably made fairly significant sacrifices” to send their only child to the fee-paying Blackrock College.
While the curriculum of the era included drawing as a subject rather than art, Blackrock taught art.
“I was lucky in the school I went to because we had an art class and a really nice and good art teacher called John Coyle,” he says.
“He spotted something in me, which I didn’t recognise, and kind of fostered an interest.”
Ballagh’s parents were less supportive of any artistic endeavour.
“I remember my mother asking me to sit down so we could have a discussion about my future, and she said: ‘I just want to say that your father and myself will support you in whatever you want to do, except art’,” he laughs.
“So I was technically forbidden from doing art, but at the time it didn’t worry me that much because what I wanted to be was a musician.”
While continuing to play music, he studied architecture at the College of Technology in Dublin “because it seemed interesting”.
He stuck it for three years, despite “the teaching staff and myself having different ideas about what architecture should be”.
The life of a musician beckoned, however, firstly with Concord and then full-time with the Chessmen, managed by Noel Pearson, who’d later produce the multi-award-winning film My Left Foot.
“We were among the most successful showbands of the time.
“We made records and were very popular with audiences in the likes of Dublin, Limerick, Belfast and Cork; less so in rural areas.”
While well paid, life on the road with the band was arduous and dangerous.
“Irish roads back then were appalling,” he says.
“You’d be playing in the likes of Derry and it would take you six hours to get there, then you’d be on stage for four hours, take all the gear down, put it in the back of the van and head back to Dublin.”
Beyond the Pale
It was the growing popularity of country and Irish music that finally convinced him to abandon his musical career in 1965.
“Once you went outside the Pale it was all the crowds wanted to hear and it did not concur with my musical tastes, to say the least,” he says.
After leaving the Chessmen, he had a number of short-lived jobs, while any days and nights were spent in Toner’s pub on Baggot Street, “an agreeable bohemian watering hole” once frequented by the likes of Brendan Behan, Patrick Kavanagh, Brian O’Nolan and Anthony Cronin.
It was in Toner’s in 1967 that Ballagh met the artist Michael Farrell, who’d been working and living in New York.
“At that stage I’d no involvement in the arts at all but I got chatting to Michael about this big commission, and he was looking for someone to work with him on it,” he says.
“He asked if I could draw a straight line and I said I could, so he says: ‘If you’re interested to work with me, the pay is a fiver a week and all your drink you can take’.”
The pair worked – and imbibed – together at Ardmore film studios on a mural that was later installed at the National Bank of Ireland’s College Green headquarters.
“I spent a couple of months working with Michael and the next minute I was pretending I was an artist,” Ballagh says.
“What I realised was because I never went to art school or anything like that I couldn’t paint in that exact, traditional style but luckily for me, the pop art thing was happening across the globe.
“Suddenly I could do something that worked and acrylic paint, which was rare in Ireland at the time, was really suited to the bright colours and shapes.”
He was soon exhibiting and remembers how “things took off extraordinarily fast”.
His work took on political themes, including the emerging conflict in the north, the US civil rights movement, and the Vietnam War.
His political inclinations came from his father, he says, but remembers “no politics were ever discussed” in the house growing up.
The father and son were only ever politically active on one occasion, when joining an anti-apartheid protest in 1970 when the South African rugby team played at Landsdowne Road.
Ballagh designed the IR£20 note featuring an image of Daniel O’Connell
“My mother was a Catholic and my father a Presbyterian, who later converted to Catholicism, and I don’t think he would’ve had any trouble talking about politics, but it was definitely not allowed,” he says.
“I discovered afterwards that my mother’s parents – my grandfather and grandmother – were on the opposite sides in the civil war in Ireland and didn’t talk for years, so my mother obviously decided we won’t be going there.
“Even to the extent, as a kid on election day I would ask who she’d be voting for, only to be told it was between my mother and the ballot box.”
It was impresario and Riverdance co-creator Moya Doherty who enlisted Ballagh as set designer for the spin-off show from the 1994 Eurovision Song Contest.
It was a project that took him all over the globe.
“Riverdance was performed on every continent apart from Antarctica – a great adventure,” he says proudly.
“As a kid I would’ve saw Radio City Music Hall in the movies and everything, and then to end up designing a show that’d be performed there was an extraordinary privilege.
“It even went to China and I designed the stage for the Great Hall of the People in Tiananmen Square in Beijing.”
In 2011, Ballagh lost his wife Betty in controversial circumstances.
The couple had been married for 33 years and had two grown-up children.
Betty (née Carabini) was a “working class girl who left school very early but she got the art thing and she understood it”.
She had initially been admitted to hospital with the “unpleasant but not terminal” stomach complaint diverticulitis.
She died from a heart attack in a Dublin hospital while waiting for an operation, and Ballagh later took legal action.
Religion is of little concern to the artist.
“If I had sufficient interest in the subject, I’d be an atheist,” he says, confirming he’s left his body to science.
His activism, like his social life, may be limited these days but Ballagh still holds forthright opinions on many issues, such as the state of Dublin and, uncharacteristically perhaps, the ‘cancelling’ of his friend James Watson, the celebrated geneticist stripped of his academic honours after making racist remarks.
He still paints on an almost daily basis and is working on The Hungry Tree, a painting that depicts a landmark tree in King’s Inns, between his home and his Arbour Hill studio.
“I’m not making art to become more famous or less famous or anything,” he says.
“I’m just doing things that mean something to me.”
Rival protests over Garvaghy Road dispute in Glasgow
By Ryan McDougall, Press Association Scotland, Belfast News Letter, November 21st, 2026
Despite both groups being in close proximity, no violence or antagonisation was apparent, and Police Scotland said no arrests were made.
Republicans and loyalists have gathered on the streets of Glasgow for opposing demonstrations over the Orange Order parade on the Garvaghy Road in Portadown.
Cairde na hÉireann, meaning Friends of Ireland, and other republican groups, flocked to the stairs outside Buchanan Galleries in the city centre, with members from loyalist groups on the other side of the stairs.
A line of police officers separated both groups, though there did not appear to be any intimidation from either side, and Police Scotland later confirmed no arrests were made.
The republican side was protesting against the recent decision from the Parades Commission, which gave the go-ahead to the Orange Order to host a walk down Garvaghy Road in the Northern Irish town for the first time in 28 years.
The loyalist side was there in support of the decision.
Additionally, the republican side flew pro-Palestine flags and banners, while the loyalist side protested against illegal immigration.
Both sides appeared to protest peacefully, with no obvious taunting or slurs heard exchanged between the two groups.
A handful of passers-by shouted their support for whichever side they favoured, but no violence took place.
In a statement posted on social media Cairde na hÉireann said: “Cairde na hÉireann would like to thank all who attended today’s demonstration of solidarity with the residents of Garvaghy Road.
“It was particularly heartening to see representation from various Republican groups banding together for one common purpose.”
The statement added: “We will stand steadfast with the Garvaghy Road community for as long as it takes. Because there’s no going back.
“Not today, not tomorrow, not ever.”